SPURIOUS ARGUMENTS
ABOUT THE SHIA

By: ABU TALIB AT-TABRIZI
Translated by: Abdullah Al- Shahin
Edited by: Ahmed Haneef
Tabrizi, Abu Talib,
Spurious arguments about the Shia/ by Abu Talib at-Tabrizi;
translated by Abdullah al- Shahin; edited by Ahmed Haneef -
Qum: Ansariyan Publications, 1380 2001.
119 p.
Original Title:
ISBN: 964-438-3389
1. Shia defense and answers.   I. Al- Shahin, Abdullah   Tr.
II. Haneef, Ahmed   Edit.     III. Title.
297.417  BP212.5

Author: Ayatulla Abu Talib Tajlil at- Tabrizi
Translator: Abdullah al- Shahin
Editor: Ahmed Haneef
Publisher: Ansariyan Publications Qum
First Edition 2001 - 1380 - 1422
second Edition 2005 - 1384 - 1426
Thamin Ali-a'immah Press
Quantity: 2000
Number of pages: 120
Size: 145 x 210 mm
ISBN: 964-438-338-9
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED AND RECORDED FOR THE PUBLISHER

Ansariyan Publications
P.B. Box 187
22, Shohada Str.
Qum , I.R.Iran
Tel: 0098 251 7741744     Fax 7742647
Email: ansarian@noornet.net

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PREFACE

The First Spurious Argument: SEEING ALLAH

The answer

The First Proof:

The Second Proof:

Proof of Application:

The Third Proof:

The Second Spurious Argument:CONSTRAINT AND FREE WILL

The answer

Quranic Verses that reject constraint

The First Kind:

The Second Kind:

The Third Kind:

The Fourth Kind:

The Fifth Kind:

The Sixth Kind:

The Seventh Kind:

The Eighth Kind:

The Ninth Kind:

The Tenth Kind:

The Eleventh Kind:

The Twelfth Kind:

The Thirteenth Kind:

Verses that refute free will

Shias interpretation of the Conception of intermediacy

The Third Spurious Argument:VISITING THE SHRINES OF THE PROPHETS, IMAMS AND SAINTS

The answer

Proving the legitimacy of visiting the Prophets shrine

The First Evidence:

The Second Evidence:

The Third Evidence:

The Fourth Evidence:

The Fourth Spurious Argument: THE INTERCESSION OF THE PROPHETS, IMAMS AND SAINTS

The answer

The First Type:

The Second Type:

The Fifth Spurious Argument:BESEECHING THE PROPHETS, IMAMS AND SAINTS

The answer

The Sixth Spurious Argument:INHERITING FROM THE PROPHETS

The answer

The Seventh Spurious Argument:THE FABRICATION THAT THE SHIAS BELIEVE THE PROPHETIC MISSION BELONGED TO IMAM ALI

The answer

The Eighth Spurious Argument:

THE TRADITIONS THAT THE PROPHET APPOINTED IMAM ALI AS GUARDIAN AND SUCCESSOR

The answer

Other sources of The Ghadir tradition

QURANIC VERSES concerning The Homage AT AL-Ghadir

The Companions pay homage to Imam Ali and congratulate him

the Linguistic meaning of Mawla

Further evidence of the significance of the tradition of al-Ghadir

The First Evidence:

The Second Evidence:

The Third Evidence:

The Fourth Evidence:

The Fifth Evidence:

The Sixth Evidence:

The Seventh Evidence:

The Eighth Evidence:

The Ninth Evidence:

The Tenth Evidence:

The Eleventh Evidence:

The Twelfth Evidence:

The Thirteenth Evidence:

The Fourteenth Evidence:

The Fifteenth Evidence:

The Sixteenth Evidence:

The Ninth Spurious Argument:WHO IS THE FAMILY OF THE PROPHET?

The answer

The Tenth Spurious Argument:THE INFALLIBILITY OF THE TWELVE IMAMS

The answer

The Eleventh Spurious Argument:THE MIRACLES OF THE IMAMS

The answer

The Twelfth Spurious Argument:NAMING PERSONS WITH NAMES SUCH AS ABDUN-NABI AND THE LIKE

The answer

The Thirteenth Spurious Argument:LOVING THE PROPHETS FAMILY

The answer

The Fourteenth Spurious Argument:EXEGESIS AND INTERPRETATION OF THE VERSES OF THE QURAN

The answer

The Fifteenth Spurious Argument:IMMODERATION

The answer

The Sixteenth Spurious Argument:SHIA OPINION ABOUT HAFSA AND AAISHA

The answer

The Seventeenth Spurious Argument:THE PEACE TREATY BETWEEN IMAM HASAN AND MUAWIYA

The answer

The Eighteenth Spurious Argument:SWEARING BY THE PROPHET AND THE IMAMS

The answer

The Nineteenth Spurious Argument:THE CRITERION FOR ACCEPTING AND REJECTING HADITHS

The answer

The Twentieth Spurious Argument:REJECTING ANALOGY AND DISCRETION

The answer

The Twenty-first Spurious Argument:JOINING THE PRAYERS

The answer

The Twenty-first Spurious Argument:JOINING THE PRAYERS

The answer

The Twenty-Second Spurious Argument:TEMPORARY MARRIAGE

The answer

The Twenty-Second Spurious Argument:TEMPORARY MARRIAGE

The answer

The Twenty-Third Spurious Argument: THE ORIGIN OF SHIISM

The answer
 Home